Greeks withdraw $894 million in a day: Is this beginning of a run on banks?
Political leaders in Athens were due to discuss an emergency government
Wednesday to deal with a possible run on banks as it emerged Greeks
withdrew almost $900 million in a single day, fearing their country
could crash out of the euro currency by the end of the week.
An interim government would take the country through to new elections on June 17, triggered by the collapse on Tuesday of talks
to form a coalition between winners of the inconclusive May 6 election.
Greeks are withdrawing euros from banks, apparently afraid of the
prospect of rapid devaluation if the country leaves the European single
currency and returns to the drachma.
President Karolos Papoulias warned of “great fear that could develop
into a panic,” the minutes of Papoulias' negotiations with political
leaders showed, according to Reuters.
The minutes also reveal Papoulias was warned by George Provopoulos,
head of the country’s central bank, that savers withdrew at least 700
million euros ($894 million) on Monday, Reuters said.
and outflows by 4:00 p.m. when I called him exceeded 600 million euros
and reached 700 million euros," the president said according to the
minutes of the meeting. "He expects total outflows of about 800 million
Several banking sources told Reuters similar amounts had also
been withdrawn on Tuesday. Nevertheless, there was no sign of panic or
queues at bank branches in Athens on Wednesday. Bankers dismissed
suggestions that a bank run was looming. A senior executive at a
large Greek bank told Reuters: "There is no bank run, no queues or
panic. The situation is better than I expected. The amount of deposit
withdrawals the president mentioned referred to three days, not one."
some were taking no risks. Jenny P., an Athens private medical clinic
receptionist originally from Ohio, told msnbc.com she had withdrawn 85
per cent of "what's left" in her bank account.
could have a new currency in a couple of days and nobody knows for sure
what will happen," she said. "There are no lines to withdraw money, but
maybe that's because many Greeks have precious little left in the bank.
Many have been surviving on [$500] 400 euros a month, which has to
cover tax, bills, food and medical costs."
She said she was planning to return to the United States amid the
economic turmoil which has left her Greek husband unemployed. "It is
hard to see what the future will be here," she said.
already been withdrawing their savings from banks at a sharp clip -
nearly a third of bank deposits were withdrawn between January 2010 and
March 2012, reducing total Greek household and business deposits to 165
A senior bank executive said there had been
withdrawals in recent days but there was no sign yet of a panic, as had
happened in April 2010 when eight billion euros were withdrawn just
before Greece obtained its first foreign bailout.
political vacuum in Greece has hampered the country’s chances of making
the budget cuts required by the European bailout deal. Without more
austerity measures, the flow of bailout money will dry up, raising the
prospect of a euro exit with all its wider ramifications.
The likelihood of a Greek exit from the euro – dubbed the "Grexit" by
commentators – is now so high that even political leaders committed to
avoid it admit preparations are under way.
Asked in an interview
whether Greece could leave the euro zone, IMF director Christine Lagarde
replied: "We certainly don't hope so, from the IMF point of view ...
but we have to be technically prepared for anything".
Will there be a run on Greek banks?
early Wednesday that there has “so far been no sign” of lines at banks
in Athens, despite the likelihood that an exit from the euro would see a
dramatic devaluation in of Greek currency.
CNBC’s John Carney raised the prospect of reduced limits on ATM withdrawals
citing a calculation by London analysts Capital Economics that if every
working-age Greek withdrew the maximum permitted ATM amount of 300
euros a day, every single deposit of Greek households would be gone
within 61 days.
“So the controls put in place in advance of an
exit from the euro would have to include not only limits on moving funds
abroad, but limiting withdrawals from ATMs and possibly declaring a
bank holiday,” Carney wrote.
In practice, however, any Greeks
lucky enough to possess any savings have already taken the precaution of
withdrawing them from banks.
“Over the last two years Greeks
withdrew approximately 70 billion euros from their bank accounts, an
amount equivalent to approximately 35 percent of Greek GDP,” Dr Michael
Arghyrou, senior economics lecturer at Cardiff Business School in Wales
“This is a negative demand shock of enormous proportions and with
increased uncertainty this trend will almost certainly accelerate. So
yes, we will almost certainly see more deposits withdrawals over the
next few days, I just hope is that they will not be so large as to lead
to a full-blown bank run.”
How likely is ‘Grexit’? Are drachma notes being printed?
year ago, it was nearly impossible to get officials and political
leaders to talk about the possibility of Greece leaving the eurozone.
Now it appears to be an open secret.
Ireland's central bank chief and European Central Bank policymaker,
Patrick Honohan, signaled on Sunday that a Greek exit might not be as
painful as previously thought.
"Technically, it can be managed,"
he told reporters. "It would be a knock to the confidence for the euro
area as a whole ... It is not necessarily fatal, but it is not
The tone from the European Commission, the EU's executive, has shifted too.
Monday, spokeswoman Pia Ahrenhilde-Hansen said: “We wish Greece will
remain in the euro and we hope Greece will remain in the euro ... but it
must respect its commitments. Greece has its future in its own hands
and it is really up to Greece to see what the response should be.”
Asked about contingencies, she did not rule them out.
quoted one European Commission official saying: "Clearly, the future of
Greece is in the Eurozone. We are working on that. The 16 other
governments in the Eurozone really are at the end of their patience with
Greece. There isn't room or any willingness to move. The decisions are
really in Athens' hands. But it doesn't look good."
However, the official response remains that a Greek exit is not being considered.
In an interview with NBC News on Wednesday, Angela Merkel, the
German Chancellor, said: "I have the will, the determination, to keep
Greece in the Eurozone. I think it will be good for Greece and good for
all of us. We want Greece to stay in the Eurozone."
commentators have pointed to a 13 percent rise in the share value of
British firm De La Rue, which is the world’s largest currency printer,
amid speculation it is best placed to pick up the contract for issuing
new versions of the drachma, the Greek currency phased out in 2002.
has remained tight-lipped on whether it is working for the Greek
government, but in the meantime an interim solution has been mooted in
which existing euro notes would be converted into drachmas by being
endorsed with an official stamp.
Would a 'Grexit' be so bad? If so, what are the alternatives?
said a Greek exit from the Eurozone would “have consequences on growth…
consequences on trade and…consequences on financial markets “. She
added: “You can certainly assume it would be quite messy."
financial institutions have a $536 million exposure to Greek debt,
according to the latest figures from the International Monetary Fund,
although almost all is borne by France, Germany and other key European
The Institute of International Finance has estimated that the global cost of a Greek exit could hit $1.2 trillion, according to the Daily Telegraph in London
. When Argentina defaulted in 2001, foreign debtors lost around 70 percent of their investments, it said.
The Telegraph said a report in Germany’s Wirtschaft Woche magazine
forecast that a Grexit would cost the Eurozone governments alone $300
billion, pushing the whole European economy – which narrowly avoided
entering recession on Tuesday by recording exactly zero quarterly growth
- into a crisis not seen since the 1930s.
Many are looking at the
possibility that Athens issues IOUs to meet salaries and key service
bills for a fixed period, much in the way California did during its
budget crunch in 2009 when it issued 'registered warrants' with a coupon
in place of dollar salaries and which banks then accepted for cash. Much
hinges on whether the European Central Bank would allow the Greek
central bank to accept such IOUs and there's little clarity on those
However, strategists believe any Greek government
IOUs would quickly act as a proxy for a new drachma and exchange values
against the euro would mostly likely plummet in practice as people
rushed to cash out - offering Greeks a glimpse of the shock of
devaluation in a euro-ised economy with euro-denominated debts.
"I'm really not sure Greece could survive for very long if external
money was cut off," said Darren Williams, economist at fund manager
AllianceBernstein. "But what an experience of IOUs may do rather quickly
is bring home to the average Greek citizen just how much more difficult
a place it is outside the bailout programme and outside the euro."
What would happen to the euro?
the huge liabilities, there is the risk that a Greek exit from the euro
would set a precedent for the possible exit of other weakened economies
including Spain and Portugal. "Opening up the Pandora's box of exit means deposit risk across the periphery,” an RBS analyst told Reuters.
Randolph, head of sovereign risk, IHS Global Insight, told the BBC: “It
would be difficult for the [European Central Bank] to keep banks
afloat. The Greek banking sector would collapse as well. What happens
next is a political question. European nations would probably not accept
another Western European country descending into chaos and collapse.”
What is the political future for Greece?
Rampant inflation, civil unrest and even a return to dictatorship could be on the cards, analysts warn.
told msnbc.com: “There will be no credit for Greek banks or the Greek
state. That could mean a shortage of basic commodities, like oil or
medicine or even foodstuffs.
The country would end up in a
volatile period. There would be institutional weakness. The worst case
scenario would be a social and economic breakdown, perhaps even leading
to a totalitarian regime.”
Henry Wilkinson, head of analysis at
the Risk Advisory Group, said: "We are entering into unknown territory
and it remains profoundly unclear what actually will happen. I wouldn't
overstate it, but I think the big concern out of all of this is that in
times of great uncertainty and hardship, more extreme parties tend to
find greater resonance with their message."
Henry Wilkinson's remarks are as good a summary of this crisis as can be found anywhere.We don't really know what will happen, but already we don't like it.The possibilities all seem to be bad.
There have even been some comparisons drawn with the financial situation in Germany in the early 1920s, when the Mark (eight years earlier, as solid as the pound or dollar) became so worthless that one billion marks bought no more than a postage stamp. I had one, in my boyhood stamp collection. It made an impression, even though I then knew next to nothing about Gernany's disastrous defeat in the Great War, and the far worse sequel that came 27 years later.
What did remain in my mind was the impression that Germans must have lost everything. Not all Germans did; there are always some who profit from disaster. But for most decent Germans, it was very much like what had happened to the South during Reconstruction.
There were no Yankees to hate, but there were the French - who were not gentle about exacting reparations for what Germany had done during the war. Most Germans believed, not without reason, that Germany's only "crime" had been to believe in Woodrow Wilson and to expect a just peace.
The present Greek situation is, of course, quite different. Greece has not lost a war, but a battle for fiscal responsibility.The laws violated were economic, rather than moral or political. Economic laws are, however, different from moral or political laws.They are unchanging, eternal facts rather than ephemeral human agreements.
Just as two plus two will always equal four (even if the calculation is made by things that look like giant bugs a million light-years from Earth) "you can't get something for nothing" is such a fact. Its formal title is "The Second Law of Thermodynamics." Its formal statement is: "In general, the total entropy of any system will not decrease other than by increasing the entropy of some other system." As an engineering student I hated thermodynamics, but the Second Law stuck in my mind because it was one of the few concepts in that unreasonable subject simple enough for anyone to understand if restated in plain English.
If a system is at equilibrium, no spontaneous processes occur unless you add energy. The energy in
can never fully equal the energy out
as usable work. So, heat flows naturally from hot to cold. Water won't flow uphill, and you cannot get more out than you put in, so there can never be a perpetual motion machine. Even God could not make a perpetual motion machine, or make two plus two equal five, or create similar absurdities.
Greek politicians have pursued political perpetual motion for decades. "Greek voters want it all now and don't want to pay for it until later." The unspoken part (which everyone understood very well) was: "when we're all dead and it's someone else's problem." Those Greeks mostly ARE all dead now, and their children and grandchildren have inherited this mortgage against Greek society. That mortgage is now headed for foreclosure. Unlike a mortgage on a house, it can't be escaped from by mailing in the keys and walking away from the debt.
Today's Greek voters don't (or won't) understand that.